Google
 
Web NASIOC.com

View Full Version : Supercharger VS. Turbocharger


Subecowboy
02-29-2000, 02:42 PM
i have been looking around the net for a reliable, fast source for a 00RS.(hopefully one i am getting in july)

so far i have found Minam turbos:fast as balls, burns oil, $4200 (!) plus installation.

JC sports not too terrebly fast, heard of JC's notorious rep, haven't seen real horsepower figures for RS, bolt-on capibilities, and $2700 , i might be able to install myself.(says bolt-on)

And Rimmer superchargers, good horsepower, not too expensive ($3000 to $3449), i don;t know why an air filter costs $449, but to rimmer it does. I also need to know how much it costs to add that f'ed up hump to the hood. Also it's dead reliable. can't raise PSI though.

anyone heard of any other kits, products?
is there any way i can use a vortech blower with after cooler? HKS? Greddy? STi? anyone?

thx,

-chris

shiv
02-29-2000, 03:10 PM
Originally posted by Subecowboy:

so far i have found Minam turbos:fast as balls, burns oil, $4200 (!) plus installation.

In nearly 20,000 miles of hard use, I haven't burned any appreciable amount of oil. I'd imagine the oil burning problem only occurs when the oil return line is routed improperly or kinked. But this applies to all turbo systems. FWIW, I'm running 10w-30 Redline synthetic.

As for installation, it's something that almost any shadetree mechanic can tackle in one day. The only work that needs to be subcontracted is the oil pan welding. Drop that off in the morning and pick that up at night when the job is done.

shiv

delectron
02-29-2000, 03:18 PM
Shiv: would it not be a good idea for me to run my 5w30 redline once I put the turbo in?

Section 8
02-29-2000, 03:30 PM
Originally posted by Subecowboy:


And Rimmer superchargers, good horsepower, not too expensive ($3000 to $3449), i don;t know why an air filter costs $449, but to rimmer it does. I also need to know how much it costs to add that f'ed up hump to the hood. Also it's dead reliable. can't raise PSI though.


-chris

Just to further complicate things, you can change intake pressure somewhat on a super charger by changing the drive gear ratio. But when you start doing that, just like turning up the boost on a turbo charger, you need to add fuel ect ect, possibly replacing your dead reliable engine with a smoking heap if not done properly (like everything else).

I thought that Rimmer now made the super charger kit available with or without that hump?

Subecowboy
02-29-2000, 03:59 PM
The reason i put $3000-$3449 is that they offer 2 types, hump($3000) and non-hump(3449) the extra $449 is for some special air filter(according to this page)
i think the Minam kit is the way to go...so far
i still haven't heard anything about the JC kit...anyone wanna come out and spill thier guts?

thx guys,
-chris

imprezive
02-29-2000, 04:04 PM
If I"m correct the minnam kit is around 2600$ in american money

Subecowboy
02-29-2000, 04:13 PM
that's stage I chief, i'm looking at the stage II

Section 8
02-29-2000, 04:13 PM
Unless you have to have forced induction soon, you might want to wait and see what Rallispec is going to offer. Seems as if eveyone who has done buisness with them is quite satisfied. (?I don't know anything about this, but I thought that I remember reading a post that said that they are working on a kit?)

TR
02-29-2000, 04:29 PM
to clarify what Rimmer offers.
they have a new kit which uses and Autoroter supercharger and an intercooler.
boost levels are from 6 - 10 lbs.
like anyone else they need to make sure that enough fuel gets to the engine to prevent engine failure.

this kit is priced at about 3000$ and should be available very soon.

like anything else, you need to :
upgrade your clutch.
make sure it is tuned properly
fasten your saftey belt

one of the major problems for all of these boost adding kits (JC, Minnam and Rimmer) has been getting parts from their suppliers.
from what I heard, Minnam has been waiting for months to get a shipment of Garrett's. Rimmer is in a similar predicarment.

hopefully Rallispec can also avoid this pitfall if they use widely available parts.
but then that could compromise kit quaility.
wow, I am glad I am not trying to build a turbo kit.

thepas
03-01-2000, 12:40 AM
Being that I had a First Gen Ford Lightning with a NICE Vortech supercharger setup, I know quite a lot about them. the thing I hate most is when your driving around normal, it feels like you have the damn Air conditioning on! this is cuz your still spinning that damn thing and it isn't helping horsepower at all, unlike a turbo kit that is free flowing when not in use.

Kyle

shiv
03-01-2000, 12:49 AM
Originally posted by delectron:
Shiv: would it not be a good idea for me to run my 5w30 redline once I put the turbo in?

I don't see anything wrong with that. Depending on your climate, you may want to go with something a little bit thicker though. Either way, it's hard to go wrong with Redline.

shiv

delectron
03-01-2000, 11:33 AM
Shiv: I live about 20 minutes away from you. (Shon, silver RS, Teins with a 1" drop)

kaminari
07-11-2000, 02:00 AM
Wow, I was just reading up on Turbo stuff...

I used to go to High School in Danville!

anyways...

my question, is the Minnam kit you guys are referring to the same as the one in the current minnam site (http://www.minnamracing.com), which is now AMR and now the AMR turbo kit?

thanks.

brandon
07-11-2000, 06:18 AM
Just to clear up once again about power robbing with superchargers and turbochargers. Superchargers do use power from the engine to run but will always give back more power than they steal, even at idle with your foot off the gas. This is only not the case when there is a bypass valve fitted such as it is on the Ford Lightening. The valve is only used to improve fuel economy at partial throttle, and is disabled almost immediatly after you put your foot down.
Turbochargers do not free flow when not in use. The turbine in the exhaust stream needs just as much power to run as the supercharger. Some of this power is gained from heat (expansion through the turbine being the so called free energy) and some of it through backpressure. The added back pressure does rob power. If sticking a big turbine in the exhaust stream did not starve some power, then free flow exhaust headers would be a huge waste of money on NA vehicles.

wastgate
07-11-2000, 05:13 PM
So what is the most reliable and easy to install kit? I autocross so I need low end torque more than high end by far. Also, I'd like something that's not too hard to take off in case something goes wrong then I could still take advantage of my warranty.

kaminari
07-11-2000, 05:59 PM
I already understood that, Brandon, but thanks anyways!

What I'm wondering about is the differences between the Minnam kit and the AMR kit (since the Minnam site now redirects to the AMR one)

-kami

NickSTi
07-11-2000, 06:45 PM
Well Shiv will enter and say oh that is what gears are for. I will argue that is why he got beaten by an NA Impreza in an autoX with this big bad Turbo.
Maybe ARG will AutoX against Shiv and we will see what happens.

NickSTi
07-11-2000, 06:52 PM
For got to put my smilie face in the above post. Aww who cares! ANTI-SHIV like Randy! http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/biggrin.gif

rrsettgast
07-11-2000, 08:39 PM
Nick,
R U talking about me? I don't know if I like the title "Anti-Shiv"...kinda makes my existance depend on Shiv...but I digress.

I belive that an autocross is not really a matter of power, but instead a matter of suspension/tires and most importantly driver skill for that type of course. Hell, you never really get out of second gear. I know that Shiv was running stock springs/cheap struts, and street tires....while Kartboy was running a coil-over setup and R-compund tires. I also know that Kartboy is a verrry experienced autoXer, while shiv doesn't really like to autoX...or so he says http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/biggrin.gif

Whatever the case, the driver is te most important thing.
Randy

Greg Sharpe
07-12-2000, 12:25 AM
The smoking Minnam problem was due to an undersized oil-feed line. It caused the oil pressure at the turbo to rise high enough to bleed through the center bearing and burn as the oil hit the blazing turbine wheel. This is no longer the case with Minnams kitsas they have upsized that oil line. I have seen more than a few here on the east coast since they released the kit, and only the first few kits had the undersized oil line. Minnam has also designed a brace into the downpipe to take the wieght of the entire turbo assembly off of the header & stock exhaust hangers.

shiv
07-12-2000, 12:48 AM
Nick,

Since this me-getting-my-assed-kicked-by-an-NA-impreza topic seems to pop up periodically, I might as well give the whole story. Unlike a lot so S. Cal. gusy, I (and the rest of the Bay area folks) only had three runs that day. For me, the first run was for orientation. 70 something seconds. Middle of the pack. Second run was cleaner and nearly 10 seconds quicker. When I was done, I was told that I won the Impreza competition since everyone was essentially done. Yea! The Funny thing was that I was told this by the infamous NA Imprezer driver who ended up with the fastest time. As it turned out, he told me that so I would think that I had already won.

Thinking that I already won, I approached my last run like most people would. Having fun, sliding around and hitting cones. Not surprisingly, I ended up with a worse time. No big deal. I mean, I had already won, right? Wrong... moments later the NA driver came up to me, shows me his slip and said "Pysch! I really won. I beat you by less than a tenth of a second!" Oookay... so second place aint so bad.

No problem. That's racing, I guess. Of course, it would be silly of me to say that I would have been faster (and won) if I knew what the true standings were. After all, racing isn't about coulda shoulda woulda. But then again, it would be a bit unrealistic to say that I couldn't have chopped another few seconds off my time if I thought I had to. Afterall, I did shed several seconds between the first and second run. I dunno. But maybe these are the tricks and games that autoxers play to win. Whatever. I don't care. I just go to have fun. I didn't think I would still be hearing about it months later.... sheesh. Nor did I think I would ever be compelled to disclose the whole dirty story. Sorry Kartboy. http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/wink.gif

shiv

PS. BTW, It's not exactly a terrible thing to be edged out by an experienced autoxer driving a well set-up car on Hoosier autox tires. If power was everything, those 116hp Miatas wouldn't kick everyones butt.

[This message has been edited by shiv (edited July 12, 2000).]

STi Sev
07-12-2000, 12:59 AM
Shiv good point about the auto-x and the last comment. Your a good sport..

hahaha Tom u sneaky bastard .. .U NEVER TOLD ME THAT SIDE OF THE STORY! hehe

remember shiv, I can make kartboy 'disapear' (you know what the cost is, *cough rx-7*cough* hehe

Just joking around..

STi Sev
07-12-2000, 01:00 AM
posted by shon
Shiv: would it not be a good idea for me to run my 5w30 redline once I put the turbo in?


Shon,
What the hell, what happened to the bike.. "wasnt the bike fast enough?"

STi Sev
07-12-2000, 01:03 AM
Just for the side note:

I've also been getting sick of this Shiv getting beat by N/A postings.

Not to name any names, but some people *cough nicksti,subepwr,MPREZYA...) like to bloat individual events into something they're not.. Why don't you guys go get a job with the media http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/smile.gif

Keiho
07-12-2000, 01:07 AM
The Minnam kit is different from the AMR kit. AMR is a totally different company, and they're still in the process of completing their turbokit. As far as JC sports goes, I think they've turned around their customer service reputation quite a bit from before.

N/A
07-12-2000, 01:29 AM
So what ever happened to the ASR turbo kit? I know that at least two people have one installed. I haven't heard anything about them since there was that north/south CA meet.

kaminari
07-12-2000, 01:57 AM
Yea, I'm still wondering about that kit...

rao
07-12-2000, 07:33 AM
Shiv,

Have you ever gotten any 1/4 mile times for your car?

the spacecowboy
07-12-2000, 12:06 PM
im kind of intereseted in jc sports turbo kit performace result.....

i appreciate anyone who has one if you could email me and tell me what you think of it...

also i have a auto tranny.....what upgrades will i have to make to it if i run turbo...

thanks,
space

Strepto
07-12-2000, 12:19 PM
Talk to Mjos. He was running a JC Sports turbo up to 14psi on his MY99 auto with no problems.

Also, look around for imfo on boosting a MY00. It seems the stock MAP sensor does not like boost!!

NickSTi
07-12-2000, 03:01 PM
Strepto - I like boost http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/wink.gif
BTW - has ANYONE gotten a Rimmer kit shipped to them after ARG? I was really calm about the situation but now. http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/mad.gif http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/mad.gif

kaminari
07-12-2000, 04:20 PM
Serious about the MY00 MAP sensor?!

Dammit.
I was hoping to turbocharge my MY00!
ugh!

63Alpine
07-12-2000, 04:29 PM
Just my opinion but a person would have to be crazy to give Rimmer money right now. There are way to many stories of people giving them money and never getting a product.

I was waiting for them to get their act together so that I could get one of their kits but I don't know at this point. They seem really shady. It is too bad htat they can't execute because the Autorotor SC is a hot package.

NickSTi
07-12-2000, 05:53 PM
I have a 2000 kaminari and it sure is not stock.

Kwez
07-12-2000, 06:26 PM
Hi, guys

I DID get a Rimmer kit (in July) ('99RS).

The Sube dealer that did the install also took care of buying the kit : no worrying for me about giving Rimmer money & nervously waiting for the goods ;-).
I think that they (dealer) had been waiting for a while to get one for their demo RS, so maybe that's why I could get one so quickly ??

I was lucky I guess !

Phil

ImprezaRS dot com
07-12-2000, 08:49 PM
I rode in Mike Jerry's JC Sports turbo impreza at an autocross, and it pulled nicely at low revs, and with nicer tires and turbo he ran a second faster than me :-(

I would have liked to see what it felt like on open road, but it was definitely more powerful than my car, even low down...

Larry www.ImprezaRS.com (http://www.ImprezaRS.com)

Red-Imp
07-12-2000, 09:40 PM
Kwez,

How do you like the Rimmer kit? Can you post a review of it after you've driven it a while?

Thanks in advance,

-Red

Mariano
07-12-2000, 09:47 PM
ATT. RAO:

You got the Autorotor kit right? How's it holding? Any oficial times?

thanxs in advance

NickSTi
07-12-2000, 09:52 PM
doooood, lift the rock http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/smile.gif
Rao got rid of his RS and got an Audi S4.

Strepto
07-12-2000, 10:05 PM
Larry, Mike Jerry's car is not a JC Sports turbo kit.

Mike Jerry has a Minnam Stage I turbo, but has adapted a JC Sports IC to the kit.

Strepto
07-12-2000, 10:08 PM
Nick, really?! I thought that the MAP was the biggest problem with boosting MY00's. Oh well, back to reading more posts http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/smile.gif

rao
07-13-2000, 07:45 AM
Marino - do a search and you will find a fair aount of discussion on it. Short version:

1. I did get the Rimmer Supercharger kit
2. It didn't work
3. I sold my car, bought an S4 and lived happily ever after http://www.i-club.com/ubb-files/smile.gif

Red-Imp
07-13-2000, 08:14 AM
RAO,

It didn't work!? That's seriously bad news to me. I really had my heart set on one. Would you mind telling me about the problems you had. You can send me a private e-mail if you don't want to start a Rimmer war on the board.

Thanks in advance,

-Red

rao
07-13-2000, 08:49 AM
All of the detail that I will share at this time is in my prior posts, do a search and they are easily found.

Red-Imp
07-13-2000, 10:51 AM
Oops. Right. MAP sensor. Been there, read that. Lost track of who's who. Stupid me.

Sorry,

-Red

Kwez
07-13-2000, 05:09 PM
Red-

my kit is not fully functional yet but at the 4-4.5psi I'm getting now it's nice.
Once everything is top shape & I have more driving experience w. it I'll let you guys know.

(PS: My car is a 99)

Phil

Red-Imp
07-13-2000, 10:05 PM
Kwez,

Thanks. I'll keep an eye out for it. I was hoping your car was an MY00 so you could tell us how they solved the MAP problem. Oh well, better for you that it isn't. From what I've read Rimmer tested the kit on a '99, so hopefully you won't have any problems.

Good luck,

-Red

kaminari
07-14-2000, 12:52 AM
NickSTI: Do you have a turbocharger on it? Which one?