Yes, well I just got it back after a warranty repair of this issue and guess what...it's broken, again. Same problem. Noticable thunk when I start to raise the window from a fully down position, and over those little multi-speed-bump clusters, something is noticably rattling inside the door. So back to the dealership it goes. This will be the third warranty service on this door from this dealership. I may just fix it myself if it happens again.
Not to mention the fact that my clutch now has the shuddering problem, mentioned in other threads. This dealership is going to hate me