The Goodyears are a brand new tire so I doubt many people have them yet. I would give them a try for sure. I wanted a set of them for wifes 06 WRX, but I could not wait till these came out and settled for the yokohama avid W4s that recently came out. My friend is a Goodyear dealer so I knew about these tires in the spring and hoped they came out before the RE92s were dead.
The Michelins are way over priced and they don't even have the 91 load rating that you should be using on an 06+ WRX.
Another proven option is the Bridgestone RE960, but for the price I would give the Goodyears a try.