Originally Posted by Spenk
And fail he will.
edit: Quick check on Autotrader.ca has a 2007 Cayman S for $69,900CAD. Brand new configuration on porsche website runs me about $77,500CAD.
As to "Would you trade in..." - such hypothetical questions are retarded. Unfortunately with high-priced sports cars, a simple test drive is unlikely to prove which one is truly a driver's car, being that the dealership would rarely let you push these cars to their limits. I'd suggest someone lend me their Cayman S and their GTR and I will settle this dispute personally.