I've got one, it works fine. Dirt cheap, too. Why would I spend $500.00 on a toll I'll use 3 times a year when one that costs $50.00 gets done what I need to get done just fine?
If I was a real mechanic, I'd spend the money on real mechanic's tools. Since I just putter, the cheap stuff works fine for me. If you buy a tool like this from HF and expect it to work using it every day, you'll be disappointed. If you buy it expecting to remove lugnuts once a month, it'll be fine.