Don't mean to thread jack but if anyone near Indianapolis has a cracked bumper, that they're going to replace and get rid of the old, I'd be interested in taking it off your hands.
call me crazy but I'm wanting to try and mod my 09 front bumper with some of the 11 design, haven't really enjoyed any of the after-market items i've seen, and definitely not the prices. I have a dark gray WRX, but the color doesn't matter, as after doing all the work it'll have to be painted anyway.
Shoot me a PM. I would come pick it up.