Should I buy a Subaru XXXX or a Subaru YYYY? We don't know. Sit in the cars, drive them, compare cost, insurance, and the 900 other variables and decide for yourself. You cannot diagnose cancer online and in the same line of reasoning we cannot decide which car is right for you without a horrendous amount of information.
Unless you can get someone near you (fill out your profile so we know where you are) to give you a second opinion, it's hard to do this over the web.
Pics might help too.
Does it have service records?