Oh, I completely agree on Vick, but I also see why people are taking him #1. If I was in a random free league I'd probably do it for S's and G's just to see what happened.
And I love looking at what people are up and down on. My list would be:
Up - Turner, Fitz, Rice, Freeman, Gore (as long as healthy), F. Jones
Down - CJ, MJD, Foster (even before his injury), Nicks, Hillis
A lot of these up's and down's are related to draft position. For example, I'm really high on Nicks in the third round, not in the first. I'm also down on CJ/AF because of them going 2-4. After that I raise my interest in them a little more (as evident by me taking CJ @ 6 in the OT league 1)