Thanks for all the criticism, guys! I figured there'd be a few people who liked the chrome better... I didn't hate the chrome myself, I just knew I'd like it more black. I think this flows better since the grill area is all black on our cars.
For anyone scared to try this... don't be. I was a bit nervous, but just followed the steps in this thread
and was fine. Trust me when I say it was a lot more painless than I thought it would be.