Thanks for the response Jamie. I was able to figure out which was the valet (by attempting to lock the glovebox). I took the non-valet key to Home Depot and the guy said that he could make a copy but it might not come out and would ruin the key. I decided to risk it and it came out perfectly. Works on everything, ignition, doors, and glovebox. Looks really great on the keyring. I showed somone the key this morning and they thought I just bought a new car
Anyhow, thanks again. I wholeheartidly reccomend this key over the STI key. It's less flashy but is still really nice and well made.