hi Collin
the 2005 Rear Bumper
list price $239.97 - - your price $179.95
item is unpainted, and very expensive to ship to NC unfortunately
it's HUUUUGE
fog covers:
as far as i can see, that black backing is not available separate from the fog light assembly itself
if i were you, i'd march back into that paint shop and have a chat with someone.... the only way to get the backing back is to order new covers... i'd make them buy them.
hope this helps and shout if we can help.
Jamie