haha yep that's what I thought of too when I first saw these wheels TSW?? Yea I know what you mean, I would feel guilty too spending money that can go paying down or off a car.
I don't mean to flood up your thread on wheel suggestion, but maybe bite off Overland style and consider these:
SSR GTVO2 18x9.5 +45
Right in your ally in price, $441 at evasivemotorsports.com, maybe cheaper somewhere else.