I figured it had to be the evaporator or the connection to it. I finally tore into the dash after reading a few posts about it being possible to get to the evaporator without removing the upper dash.
I had previously replaced the cabin filter so I knew partially what I was getting into. This time I removed the glove box as done for a cabin filter change (10 or so Philips screws) and also the blower motor assembly (two 10mm bolts and several more Philips screws), several electrical connections and a few electronic controllers.
I was able to get to the evaporator and found the leak. I think this took about 2 hours without instructions of any kind including removal of the AC connections at the firewall. Keep in mind I am waiting for the replacement part (RockAuto $85 shipped vs $200+ for Subaru).



I hadn't read anything real definitive about doing this on an Impreza MY05 so I hope this is helpful to someone.